Help guides

Start an editorial review

Choose what kind of review to run, which chapters to read, and tap the question mark to see roughly what it uses.

Steps

  1. Open the Feedback tab in the right-hand panel (if the panel is closed, open it from the tab on the right edge). Press Scan in the header of the tab to open the Scan menu: "Scan this chapter" and "Scan whole novel". While the tab is empty the same choices also sit in the middle of it, as Scan chapter and a whole-novel button. None of them starts a review: each opens the window "Start an editorial review", where you choose what to include. "Scan this chapter" reviews the chapter you have open, and "Scan whole novel" reviews every chapter. The choices are greyed out while another review is running, and the chapter one is greyed out when no chapter is open.
    Step 1 of 4. Open the Feedback tab in the right-hand panel (if the panel is closed, open it from the tab on the right edge). Press Scan in the header of the tab to open the Scan menu: "Scan this chapter" and "Scan whole novel". While the tab is empty the same choices also sit in the middle of it, as Scan chapter and a whole-novel button. None of them starts a review: each opens the window "Start an editorial review", where you choose what to include. "Scan this chapter" reviews the chapter you have open, and "Scan whole novel" reviews every chapter. The choices are greyed out while another review is running, and the chapter one is greyed out when no chapter is open.
  2. Under "1. What kind of review" choose a preset card. Each card shows what it checks and how many topics it covers: Full Developmental Review (story architecture, continuity, character arc and theme across the whole manuscript), Line Pass (scene construction, point of view and line craft, chapter by chapter), Query Prep (market positioning and opening pages), Continuity Check (plot holes, timeline and internal logic only) and Complete Review (every topic). Opening from the whole novel starts on Full Developmental Review, and opening from one chapter starts on Line Pass. Under "2. Chapters" you see "All N chapters" when every chapter is chosen. Press Choose chapters to pick fewer: tick the chapters you want, or use All chapters, Active chapter only and Clear selection, then Hide list to fold it away again. Title pages, dedications and other front or back matter are never read, so a selection of only those cannot start. Press "3. Customize topics" (shown with "N of N selected") and Show if you want to choose single topics instead of a preset. Each topic card says whether it reads the Whole manuscript or Per chapter. Select all groups and Clear are there to start over. Changing any topic by hand unlights the preset, which is fine.
    Step 2 of 4. Under "1. What kind of review" choose a preset card. Each card shows what it checks and how many topics it covers: Full Developmental Review (story architecture, continuity, character arc and theme across the whole manuscript), Line Pass (scene construction, point of view and line craft, chapter by chapter), Query Prep (market positioning and opening pages), Continuity Check (plot holes, timeline and internal logic only) and Complete Review (every topic). Opening from the whole novel starts on Full Developmental Review, and opening from one chapter starts on Line Pass. Under "2. Chapters" you see "All N chapters" when every chapter is chosen. Press Choose chapters to pick fewer: tick the chapters you want, or use All chapters, Active chapter only and Clear selection, then Hide list to fold it away again. Title pages, dedications and other front or back matter are never read, so a selection of only those cannot start. Press "3. Customize topics" (shown with "N of N selected") and Show if you want to choose single topics instead of a preset. Each topic card says whether it reads the Whole manuscript or Per chapter. Select all groups and Clear are there to start over. Changing any topic by hand unlights the preset, which is fine.
  3. Read the Review summary: the word count, then a line saying how long it takes. The bar at the bottom says the same in one line, such as "12 chapters · 4 topics", and the question mark beside it shows roughly what the review uses. A very short selection gets a gentle note that a review may have little to say. Every review also records a few passages that are working, with the technique behind each, and the estimate includes it. What it records is kept apart from your list of things to fix.
    Step 3 of 4. Read the Review summary: the word count, then a line saying how long it takes. The bar at the bottom says the same in one line, such as "12 chapters · 4 topics", and the question mark beside it shows roughly what the review uses. A very short selection gets a gentle note that a review may have little to say. Every review also records a few passages that are working, with the technique behind each, and the estimate includes it. What it records is kept apart from your list of things to fix.
  4. If you do not have enough credits, a message says so with a way to get more; you can also choose fewer topics or chapters. If a review is already running, the button reads "Review already running" and you start the next one when it finishes. Otherwise press "Start an editorial review". It reads "Starting review…" for a moment and the window closes. You can close this window and keep working; the review keeps running. When it finishes, read what it found in the Feedback tab. See the guide titled The Feedback tab: what the review found.
    Step 4 of 4. If you do not have enough credits, a message says so with a way to get more; you can also choose fewer topics or chapters. If a review is already running, the button reads "Review already running" and you start the next one when it finishes. Otherwise press "Start an editorial review". It reads "Starting review…" for a moment and the window closes. You can close this window and keep working; the review keeps running. When it finishes, read what it found in the Feedback tab. See the guide titled The Feedback tab: what the review found.

Questions

How many credits will it use?
Tap the question mark beside the bar at the bottom to see roughly what the review uses, as a share of this month's credits first. It changes as you change chapters and topics. The usage ring shows how much of the month's credits are used. StoryClerk never charges your card unless you choose to buy more.
Which preset should I pick?
Full Developmental Review for the big picture of a draft, Line Pass for a chapter-by-chapter polish, Query Prep before you send the book out, Continuity Check when you only want plot holes and timeline, and Complete Review for everything together.
Can I review just one chapter?
Yes. Choose "Scan this chapter" in the Scan menu, or press Choose chapters in the window and tick the ones you want.
Why is the Start button greyed out?
Either no chapter or no topic is chosen, a review is already running, or you do not have enough credits. The line at the bottom says "Select at least 1 chapter and 1 review topic to start." when something is missing.
Can I keep writing while it runs?
Yes. Close the window and carry on. The review keeps running and its results appear in the Feedback tab.

All help guides